Ask an expert

Get free help from our community of tradespeople

Stud wall too thick, who is to blame?

Posted by Jane Ford, on
I've had a stud wall built at the top of stairs, effectively extending front bedroom. I did not specify dimensions simply said it was to come from stairs up. The carpenter has used 4x2 studding faced with plaster board, leaving the doorway to bedroom only 27" without door housing, so to narrow for a narrow door. In response the carpenter claims I should have told him I was intending to have a door put on the bedroom. On the stairwell side the new plaster board sits 25mm off the plaster work below, carpenters answer " the plasterer can remove old plaster or use architrave to hide the joint, The new wall is not flush against the existing newel post, gap 30mm, answer put a fillet of wood in between, There is a strip of plasterboard missing at the top, answer Yes I couldn't reach. The bedroom floor is laminated & I had left a 50mm gap at the side to accommodate a new wall, instead the new 1200mm thick wall sits on top of laminate, answer if you change the laminate you can cut that bit off. The wall I have built is straight. The plasterboard on one edge is not flush with the stud work, answer the plasterer can fill that. The carpenter says he has built a straight wall & if I'd wanted something else I should have provided a drawing. I don't doubt it is straight, however it joins an existing wall which clearly is not straight & therefore the new bit needed to be angled accordingly. I feel let down & will be having the wall removed & redone, should the carpenter bear some responsibility?
Mostafa Tavengar

Mostafa Tavengar

Hi Jane, Obviously it is hard to comment without hearing the other point of view and seeing the job, however, what appalling customer service! I am really sorry you have had such an unpleasant experience with an independent tradesman, it reflects badly on all of us. I would have thought that it is commn sense to assume someone would want a door on their bedroom, and if you can't reach part of the job then don't accept the job in the first place! It is the best and worst aspect of working direct for the homeowner. You get to communicate directly with the person who will be living with what you create, and tailor your work according to their needs but sometimes it is hard to deal with unrealistic expectations and it is those times that you need to put your "the customer is always right" hat on and reach some sort of compromise. We have stripped an entire bathroom of tiling that had been done the day before because the customer decided she didn't like the tiles she had chosen once she saw them up! For no charge! Because it is important that she loves her new bathroom, otherwise why bother? As tradesmen we learn to accept that sometimes you will lose on a job but gain in reputation and that is where your carpenter needs a reality check. I doubt it will be worth chasing him for money if he has been so unhelpful thus far, I think you may have to put this down to experience and move on for the sake of your sanity. However, I also doubt he will be in business for long with that sort of attitude. I wish you luck with the rest of your build and suggest you be a bit more specific about what you want with your next tradesman. Mostafa Bedford Building Maintenance
Jeff Adams

Jeff Adams

Hi it seem strange that the tradesman has been alllowed to carry on for so long with no challenging. As the previous person stated. there has to be dialogue and even drawings. Hearsay is not always helpfull. Also the word do what you think is best regards

What would you like to do now?

Find more questions Create my Job

Homeowner stories

Homeowner stories - Nick

Nick shares his story of finding local tradespeople in his new area.

app-icon

Get our app for homeowners

  • Send messages and get notifications from tradespeople
  • Add photos to get more accurate quotes
  • View tradespeople’s profiles