For landlords and property managers, decisions about window maintenance are governed by safety, legality, and economics. Unlike general wear and tear on décor, the structural integrity and functionality of windows fall firmly under the landlord’s legal obligations.
The primary legal requirement, outlined in Section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, dictates that the landlord must keep the structure and exterior of the dwelling, including windows, in good repair. This means ensuring they are weather-tight, free from serious rot, and lock securely. Compliance is non-negotiable.
The economic decision: Repair versus replacement
When a tenant reports an issue, the first decision is whether to repair the defect or undertake a costly full replacement. Repairing a window is often the most cost-effective and fastest solution for rental properties, especially if the window is structurally sound and under 20 years old.
When repair is the best choice (High ROI)
- Security Issues: A jammed uPVC multi-point lock mechanism can almost always be replaced by a uPVC window specialist for a fraction of the cost of a new window.
- Failed Seals: Condensation between the glass requires an IGU (Insulated Glass Unit) replacement, which reuses the existing frame.
- Timber Mechanics: A broken sash cord, failed pulley, or minor timber rot should be repaired by a specialist restoration service.
When replacement is unavoidable
Full replacement is only recommended when the structural integrity of the frame is compromised or the window no longer meets current safety standards.
- Extensive Rot/Damage: If more than 50% of a timber frame is decayed, or if an old uPVC frame is warping or failing structurally.
- Legal Compliance: If the existing window is single-glazed and needs upgrading to meet minimum thermal standards or if a window in a habitable room doesn’t meet fire escape (egress) regulations.
| Window Issue | Professional Solution | Cost Effectiveness |
| Broken sash cord | Sash cord replacement/rebalancing. | High ROI. Minimal labour cost for a fitter. |
| Jammed uPVC lock | Window specialist (mechanism replacement). | High ROI. Mechanism replacement is far cheaper than the full frame. |
| Condensation between glass | IGU (Insulated Glass Unit) replacement. | Good ROI. Replaces the faulty seal without disturbing the frame. |
| Heavy timber rot | Full replacement (unless a heritage property). | Low ROI on repair. Extensive rot compromises weatherproofing and security. |
Landlord vs. tenant responsibilities
Clear documentation is vital to avoid deposit disputes. The line between landlord and tenant responsibility is usually drawn at negligence.
- Landlord Responsibility (Structure & Function): Repairing structural elements (frames, glass), ensuring the window is weather-tight, and fixing mechanical failures due to age or defect (failed lock mechanism, broken hinge, rotting frame).
- Tenant Responsibility (Negligence): Damage caused by tenant misuse, neglect, or accident (e.g., forcing a jammed lock, cracking a pane of glass due to impact). The cost, caused by proven negligence, can be legally deducted from the deposit, provided the deposit is protected under a scheme.
Financial planning and maintenance for rental properties
Landlords should adopt a proactive stance to minimise reactive, expensive call-outs.
- Scheduled Inspection: Include a detailed window inspection by a window fitter as part of your annual property check. This allows you to catch minor issues (blocked weep holes, loose hinges) before they escalate to major failures.
- Planned Maintenance: Budget for preventative maintenance, such as re-sealing external perimeter gaps every 5-7 years and re-lubricating all multi-point locks annually. This extends the lifespan of the mechanism and ensures compliance.
- Replacement Compliance: If replacement is necessary, always ensure the new units are installed by a FENSA/Certass registered fitter. This provides the necessary certificate, protecting your investment and guaranteeing compliance with all rental property laws (especially Part L and Part F).
By prioritising high-ROI repair and performing preventative maintenance, landlords can meet their legal obligations reliably and avoid the high, unscheduled cost of window replacements for years to come.
With Rated People, you have the power to get it done. Find a trusted, local tradesperson today.
